Gary Neville has voiced serious concerns that Manchester United’s tendency to allow too many goals may not be a short‑term glitch but a deeper problem that could linger into the season. His worries grew after United surrendered two goals for the third consecutive match, this time at Everton’s Goodison Park, culminating in a 2‑2 draw that left the Red Devils with just four points from three games.
Despite the disappointing result, midfielder‑turned‑coach Michael Carrick tried to put a positive spin on the opening fixtures, describing United’s start as "not that bad" even though the late equaliser from Everton forced the match into a stalemate. Carrick’s optimism, however, does little to calm Neville, who sees the six goals the side has let in as a glaring red flag. He doubts that Carrick can resolve the defensive frailties with the current squad, especially when the back line appears unsettled and prone to frequent changes. Neville explained that the defensive issues add extra pressure on United ahead of a crucial clash with Manchester City next week and a mid‑week European fixture.
"Michael Carrick is trying to build trust with his players and the fans that he can replicate what he achieved last season," Neville said, but he warned that United’s recent performance suggests they are not yet there. "That game should have been won today. Everton were not threatening in the first half; they only turned it around later.
Their ability to come back shows how vulnerable United are." He highlighted the pattern of conceding goals as a liability that “isn't going away.” According to Neville, the defensive lapses are likely to “hunt them down the road,” especially when the manager has already deployed his preferred back four yet still sees players like Luke Shaw and Diogo Dalot withdrawn in the final five minutes. He also noted that former United defender Ruben Amorim and head coach Erik ten Hag have tinkered with the defensive lineup during the match, a sign of uncertainty.
"You can't keep rotating your back four when you don’t have a clear hierarchy behind the first‑choice defenders," Neville argued. "There simply isn’t enough depth to justify constant changes, and that instability feeds the problem." The match’s dramatic moment came when Everton’s Ainsley Maitland‑Niles, making his debut for the Toffees, struck a stunning 25‑yard equaliser in stoppage time.
While Neville praised the quality of the strike, he expressed frustration at United’s lack of organisation in the lead‑up to the goal. He said United’s defensive structure broke down, allowing the ball to find its way to Maitland‑Niles with relative ease.
Neville emphasised that conceding two goals per game is unsustainable. "You can’t keep giving opponents two chances to score," he said. "Since the transfer window, there have been endless questions about our defence, and today we failed to protect a lead.
Some analysts might call the goals ‘spectacular,’ but the reality is that we allowed them because of basic errors." He singled out a specific mistake involving defender Tyrell Dorgu, who, Neville claimed, “chased out and pressed in isolation,” creating a gap that was exploited. The subsequent pass bypassed Dorgu, leading directly to the equaliser – a “massive mistake” and a clear sign of poor communication among the back line. The substitution of Yoro at right‑back further underlined the issue; Neville criticised Yoro’s narrow positioning, which limited his ability to cover the flank effectively.
Neville also stressed that defensive lapses often occur before the ball even reaches the net. "A lot happens before the goal is scored. When you’re playing away and trying to protect a result, you must stay compact and avoid foolish decisions. United could have stopped that goal at its source," he said, recalling how he shouted in disbelief as the ball crossed the line.
Reflecting on his own playing days, Neville recalled a period between the Peter Schmeichel and Edwin van der Sar eras when opponents occasionally believed they could break down United’s defence at Old Trafford. "Back then, we weren’t always defensively solid, and teams felt they had a chance to score against us.
That mindset is dangerous, and it’s exactly what we’re seeing now – opponents sense vulnerability and act on it," he warned. The broader implication of Neville’s comments is that United must address both tactical and personnel issues to stop the trend of leaking goals. Consistency in the defensive lineup, clearer communication, and perhaps strategic signings in the transfer market could be essential steps. Until then, the fear remains that United’s defensive frailties will continue to be exploited by rivals, jeopardising their ambitions in both domestic and European competitions.
In summary, while Carrick tries to reassure supporters that the early season performances are not catastrophic, Neville’s analysis suggests that United’s defensive woes are more systemic than superficial. The club’s ability to tighten up at the back, maintain a settled back four, and improve collective concentration will be decisive in determining whether they can halt the goal‑conceding trend before it becomes a season‑long handicap. Play Super 6 for a chance to win £1m!
Enter for free.