Jamie Carragher has publicly urged that Manchester City be stripped of the honours they collected after an independent commission concluded that the club committed serious breaches of the Premier League’s financial regulations. The commission determined that City were guilty of every charge relating to violations of the league’s financial rules for the seasons spanning 2009/10 through 2017/18 – a period in which the Sky Blues captured three Premier League crowns, one FA Cup, three League Cups and a Community Shield.
The club, which continues to deny any wrongdoing, has said it will appeal the decision and has until Friday, 2 October, to lodge its challenge. A subsequent hearing will decide the exact sanctions, which could range from points deductions and hefty fines to transfer bans or even expulsion from the top flight.
But what would the football landscape look like if the titles and trophies were taken away from City? ### How the Premier League titles might be reassigned Between 2009/10 and 2017/18 Manchester City lifted the league trophy three times. The first came in dramatic fashion in 2012, when Sergio Aguero’s last‑minute strike snatched the crown from Manchester United on the final day. Two years later, City edged out Liverpool by a narrow two‑point margin to claim the 2014 title.
Then, in 2018, they set a new benchmark by amassing 100 points, again denying United the prize. If the league decided simply to award those championships to the runners‑up, the record books would be altered dramatically. Manchester United would gain two additional titles – one under Sir Alex Ferguson and another under Ole Gunnar Solskjær – taking their total to fifteen. Liverpool would be credited with a second Premier League crown, adding to the one they won under Jürgen Klopp in 2020.
However, stripping City of their titles does not automatically mean that every club below them would move up a place in the final tables. One possible approach is to leave the championships vacant, as was done when Juventus were stripped of the 2004/05 Serie A title after the Calciopoli scandal; the season’s title simply remained unassigned. Another, more radical option would be to expunge Manchester City’s league record for the nine seasons in question. Removing all of City’s results would reshuffle points totals across the board, potentially altering final positions for many clubs.
Even in that scenario, the title would likely be reassigned to the highest‑placed team after the expungement – meaning United and Liverpool would still emerge as champions for the respective seasons. ### Ripple effects on relegation and European qualification The consequences of erasing City’s results extend beyond the title race.
In the 2010/11 campaign, Blackpool would have escaped relegation had City’s points been removed, while Wolves would have taken their place in the drop zone. European competition would also be reshaped.
In four of the nine seasons under scrutiny, Everton missed out on a Europa League spot because City finished ahead of them. In the 2013/14 season, Everton finished fifth and qualified for the Europa League, but the top four – including City as champions – earned Champions League berths, pushing Everton out of the premier continental tournament.
Tottenham Hotspur were denied Champions League football in four seasons during the same period, as City’s higher league position forced Spurs into the Europa League each time. Similarly, Manchester United, Arsenal and Chelsea lost out on Champions League qualification in various years because City occupied a higher slot. Liverpool, Swansea City and Southampton also saw their chances of European competition curtailed by City’s superior finishes. ### Cup competitions and personal grievances City’s success was not limited to the league.
In the 2011 FA Cup final, Tony Pulis, then manager of Stoke City, watched his side lose 1‑0 to a City side that claimed its first major trophy in 35 years; Pulis later described the defeat as a "cheated" experience. The Sky Blues also secured three League Cup victories – beating Sunderland in 2014, Liverpool in 2016 and Arsenal in 2018 – and lifted the 2012 Community Shield against Chelsea. Sunderland, whose last major honour dates back to the 1973 FA Cup, have yet to add another piece of silverware, while Jürgen Klopp was denied his first trophy when City won the 2016 League Cup on penalties. Arsène Wenger, in his final season at Arsenal, was also prevented from ending his tenure with a cup win.
### What could happen next? The independent commission will soon announce the specific penalties, and Manchester City will file an appeal. If the league opts for a points deduction, the club could see its standing in the current season plummet, potentially affecting qualification for European tournaments. A transfer ban would limit City’s ability to sign new players, while a fine would hit the club’s finances directly.
The most severe sanction – expulsion from the Premier League – would be unprecedented in modern English football and would trigger a cascade of legal and logistical challenges. Regardless of the final decision, the debate sparked by Carragher’s comments highlights how financial compliance is intertwined with sporting integrity. Fans, pundits and former players are already speculating about how the history books might be rewritten, how clubs that narrowly missed out on European football would have fared, and whether the Premier League will set a new precedent for punishing financial misconduct. The outcome will shape not only Manchester City’s legacy but also the broader conversation about fairness and accountability in the sport.
Play Super 6 for a chance to win £1m! Enter for free.