EFL clubs have collectively voiced their disapproval of the plan to introduce a VAR challenge system for managers in the Championship. According to Sky Sports News, the Professional Game Management Office (PGMO) presented a demonstration of how the challenge mechanism would function during the EFL’s annual meeting last month, after being asked by the league to showcase the proposal and gather feedback from the clubs. The response from the clubs was overwhelmingly negative, and as a result the league has decided to keep the current arrangement for the upcoming season: there will be no VAR in the EFL, with only goal‑line technology remaining in the Championship.
Meanwhile, VAR will continue to be used in the Premier League despite a recent poll that highlighted its unpopularity among supporters. In late March, the Football Supporters' Association conducted a survey of roughly 8,000 fans across the 20 Premier League clubs. The findings were stark: three‑quarters of respondents (75%) said they were against the use of VAR, and a staggering 90% disagreed with the notion that VAR has enhanced the match‑day experience.
Moreover, 91% felt that VAR has taken away the spontaneity of goal celebrations, and 94% believed that the technology does not make watching football on television any more enjoyable. The Championship can still be streamed on Sky via the NOW platform, and viewers are advised to use the Chrome browser for the most accessible video player experience. At the same time, the scope of VAR’s authority is being broadened by the sport’s governing bodies.
Starting this summer, officials will have the option to employ VAR to review corner‑kick situations in certain competitions, although the core VAR protocol will also be expanded to include checks on second yellow cards. Lawmakers have stressed that any VAR review of corners must not delay the restart of play and will be limited to correcting clear and obvious errors. In other words, corner‑kick reviews will be optional rather than a mandatory component of the VAR system.
Similarly, VAR will now be permitted to intervene only when a second yellow card has been incorrectly awarded. The technology will not be used to suggest a second booking in cases where the referee did not initially see a caution. This refinement aims to curb the over‑reach of VAR while still providing a safety net for obvious mistakes.
The debate over VAR’s role in English football continues to polarise fans, clubs, and officials. Proponents argue that the technology helps eliminate glaring errors that can decide the outcome of matches, thereby promoting fairness and integrity. Critics, however, contend that the interruptions caused by VAR reviews disrupt the flow of the game, diminish the emotional immediacy of scoring moments, and often lead to confusing or inconsistent decisions.
The recent EFL club opposition to a manager‑focused challenge system reflects a broader reluctance to add another layer of complexity to an already contentious tool. The challenge system that was proposed would have allowed managers to request a VAR review of a specific decision, much like a coach’s challenge in American football or tennis. Supporters of the idea suggested it could give managers a tactical avenue to correct potentially game‑changing errors, while opponents feared it would lead to strategic abuse, longer stoppages, and further erosion of the sport’s natural rhythm.
The clubs’ feedback during the PGMO demonstration evidently tipped the scales toward maintaining the status quo for the Championship. Looking ahead, the Premier League’s commitment to retaining VAR suggests that the top tier will continue to experiment with refinements, such as the optional corner reviews and the narrowed focus on second‑yellow‑card incidents.
Whether these adjustments will address the concerns raised by fans—particularly the loss of spontaneous celebration and the perceived decline in viewing pleasure—remains to be seen. In the meantime, the EFL’s decision to forgo a VAR challenge system means that managers in the Championship will continue to rely on the traditional on‑field judgments of referees, supplemented only by goal‑line technology to confirm whether the ball has crossed the line.
The league’s stance also underscores the importance of club input in shaping the future of officiating technology, a process that is likely to continue as the sport evolves. Fans interested in following Championship action can tune in via Sky’s NOW streaming service, ensuring they have the best possible viewing experience by using a compatible browser like Chrome.
As the season unfolds, the conversation around VAR will undoubtedly keep evolving, with stakeholders on all sides watching closely to see how the balance between technological assistance and the pure, unedited flow of the game can be best achieved. Play Super 6 for a chance to win £250k!
Enter for free.